Last reviewed: .

Every spring, across Houston, Dallas–Fort Worth, Austin, and San Antonio, commercial mechanical, electrical, plumbing, civil, concrete, drywall, and roofing contractors send their year-end financial statements to their construction CPA for a CPA Reviewed or Audited Financial Statement required by their surety company. Two weeks later, the owner gets a phone call that stops them cold:

“Your internal QuickBooks P&L showed $1.9M in net profit, including $680,000 of Underbillings on the balance sheet. After testing your open Work-in-Progress (WIP) schedule against current job-to-date costs and signed change orders, $510,000 of those Underbillings are actually unbillable cost overruns. Your true net profit is $1.39M—and your surety just froze your single-job bonding limit.”

Even worse, if that same discovery happens 45 days after you sign a Letter of Intent (LOI) to sell your contracting business at a 5.5x EBITDA multiple, a $510,000 WIP Underbilling write-down doesn’t just reduce your Net Working Capital by $510,000—it slashes your headline purchase price by $2,805,000 ($510K × 5.5x).

1. How the Cost-to-Cost WIP Formula Manufactures Phantom “Underbilling” Profits

To understand why Underbillings are so dangerous, look at how the standard ASC 606 cost-to-cost percentage-of-completion formula works on a single commercial subcontract:

  • Suppose you bid a $2,000,000 commercial HVAC or electrical package on a Frisco medical office building with an Estimated Total Job Cost of $1,500,000 (a 25.0% estimated gross margin, or $500,000 gross profit).
  • By Month 6, your field crews hit rock-hard conditions, coordination delays, and unapproved scope changes. You have already spent $1,200,000 in actual labor and materials (`80.0%` of your original `$1,500,000` cost budget).
  • However, when your project manager walks the job with the General Contractor’s superintendent to sign the monthly `AIA G702/G703` pay application, the GC inspects the physical pipe and duct hung in the ceiling and rightly says: “You are only 60.0% physically complete. I am only approving 60% of the contract value ($1,200,000) on this month’s pay app.”
  • Here is where the accounting illusion happens: If your project manager refuses to raise the job’s Estimated Cost at Completion from `$1,500,000` to the true `$2,000,000` it will actually take to finish, the accounting software sees `$1,200,000` spent out of `$1,500,000` (`80%` cost complete), multiplies `80% × $2,000,000 contract = $1,600,000 earned revenue`, compares it to the `$1,200,000` billed to the GC, and books a $400,000 Underbilling Asset (`CIEB`) and $400,000 of phantom gross profit!
  • In reality, you haven’t earned an extra `$400,000` that you forgot to bill—you are 60% done with the job, you have burned 80% of your budget, and your profit has evaporated (`Profit Fade`).

2. How Surety Underwriters & M&A QoE Auditors Haircut a Contractor’s Balance Sheet

In Texas commercial construction, your aggregate bonding capacity is governed by the 10x to 15x Adjusted Working Capital Rule (e.g., `$1.5M` in surety-approved Adjusted Working Capital supports a `$15M to $22.5M` aggregate bonded backlog). Simultaneously, M&A buyers audit the exact same WIP schedule during Contractor WIP Diligence. Compare how both parties treat your balance sheet lines:

Surety Underwriter & M&A QoE Treatment of Texas Contractor Balance Sheet & WIP Items
Balance Sheet / WIP Line Item Surety “Adjusted Working Capital” Credit M&A Quality of Earnings (QoE) Treatment Impact of a $400K Disallowance
Unrestricted Operating Cash & Progress AR < 90 Days 100% Credit toward Adjusted Working Capital. 100% accepted (Cash retained by seller in CFDF; AR < 90 days counts toward NWC Peg). Baseline bankable liquidity.
Contract Retainage Receivable (Texas Prop. Code Ch. 53) 100% Credit (if bonded/collectible within 12 months). Included in Net Working Capital Peg if historical collection rate is ≥98%. Must track retainage aging by project closeout date.
Underbillings / CIEB on Early-Stage Jobs (<30% Complete) 50% to 100% Credit only if billed on the next month’s AIA G702 pay app. Verified via Subsequent Event Billing Test (did the GC approve and pay it within 30 days?). Harmless if caused purely by a 20th-of-the-month billing cutoff.
Chronic Underbillings / CIEB on Jobs >60% Complete 0% to 50% Credit (50%–100% Haircut) as suspected Profit Fade or unapproved COs. Written off 100% against TTM EBITDA and Closing NWC unless backed by a signed GC Change Order. Cuts bonding limit by $4M–$6M OR cuts sale price by $2.0M+ at 5.0x EBITDA.
Net Overbillings / BIE (Billings in Excess of Cost) Viewed favorably as Positive Cash-Flow Discipline (GC is financing the job). Treated as a normal working-capital liability (or partial deferred-revenue debt if cash was distributed out). Target a consistent 6%–12% Net Overbilled ratio kept inside operating cash.
AR > 90 Days, Unapproved Claims & Officer Loans 0% Credit (100% Disallowed) by surety underwriters. Excluded 100% from NWC; officer loans must be zeroed out pre-close. Immediate dollar-for-dollar working capital reduction.

3. The M&A QoE “24-Month Closed-Job Gross Margin Fade Look-Back Test”

When a private equity platform or strategic acquirer audits a Texas contractor, their construction accounting team runs a diagnostic called the Closed-Job Profit Fade Look-Back:

  1. They pull your monthly WIP schedules from 24 months ago, 12 months ago, and today, and trace every job that crossed $250,000 in contract value from start to finish.
  2. If your open WIP schedules consistently forecast 26% gross margin when jobs are 50% complete, 24% gross margin at 75% complete, and then suddenly drop to 15% gross margin in the final two months of punch-list and closeout, the QoE report flags Systematic Late-Stage Profit Fade (`-1100 bps`).
  3. Based on that historical fade pattern, the buyer’s accountants will apply a pro-forma margin reserve across all currently open jobs in your backlog—reducing your trailing-12-month (`TTM`) Adjusted EBITDA and triggering a massive re-trade during exclusivity.

4. The 4-Step Monthly WIP Scrub to Eliminate Underbillings & Expand Bonding Capacity

Whether you want to double your Texas surety bonding capacity to bid larger projects or prepare for a premium-multiple sale in the next 12 to 24 months, install these four monthly WIP rules immediately:

  1. Front-Load the AIA G702/G703 Schedule of Values (`SOV`) Before Mobilization.

    As detailed in our 13-Week Contractor Cash-Flow & SOV Playbook, never submit an evenly weighted Schedule of Values. Assign explicit, defensible line-item values to Submittals, BIM/CAD Coordination, Engineering, Permits, Trench Safety, Mobilization, and Early Rough-In so your first two pay apps put every project into a 6% to 12% Net Overbilled (`BIE`) position from Day 1.

  2. Ban Unapproved Change Orders From the WIP Contract Value Column.

    The fastest way to create toxic Underbillings is allowing a project manager to add a `$75,000` verbal field directive into the WIP schedule’s Revised Contract Amount before the GC signs a formal Change Order. Enforce our Change-Order Discipline Rule: incurred costs on pending extra work hit the job immediately, while revenue is recognized at `$0` until the bilateral CO is signed.

  3. Run a Monthly “Physical Field % Complete vs. Accounting Cost % Complete” Audit.

    On the 5th business day of every month, require the Controller, Operations Manager, and Project Manager to review every active job where Incurred Cost % exceeds Billed % by more than `5%`. If a job has spent `70%` of its labor hours (`see our` Job-Costing Playbook) but is only `55%` physically installed in the field, immediately raise the Estimated Cost to Complete (`ETC`) on that month’s WIP schedule rather than hiding the overrun inside Underbillings.

  4. Upgrade to a Construction-Specialized CPA Review & Clean Up Surety GIAs Early.

    A generalist tax CPA who only files a cash-basis tax return once a year will leave your WIP schedule unprepared for buyer diligence. Retain a Texas construction CPA firm (`CFMA` member) to perform quarterly or annual AICPA-compliant WIP reviews, and review our guide on Releasing Personal Guarantees on Surety Bonds (GIAs) When Selling.

5. Three Real-World Texas Contractor WIP & Bonding Scenarios

  • Scenario A — $11.4M DFW Commercial Mechanical & Plumbing Contractor (Doubling Bonding Capacity): A Grand Prairie commercial HVAC/plumbing contractor carried `$820,000` in chronic Underbillings (`CIEB`) against only `$190,000` in Overbillings (`BIE`). Their surety disallowed 75% of the Underbillings, capping their aggregate bonding program at `$12M`. Over three quarters, we instituted mandatory SOV mobilization front-loading, wrote off `$310,000` of dead change-order claims at tax year-end, and enforced monthly PM cost-to-complete scrubs. Twelve months later, the balance sheet showed `$610,000` in Overbillings and only `$120,000` in current-cutoff Underbillings (`+$490,000` Net Overbilled)—and the surety expanded their aggregate bonding limit from `$12M` to `$25M`.
  • Scenario B — $7.9M Houston Commercial Electrical Contractor (Preventing a $1.1M QoE Retrade): During a pre-market Business System Inspection for a Houston commercial electrical contractor preparing for sale, we discovered `$390,000` of Underbillings sitting on four jobs that were `85%+` complete. Our line-by-line review revealed that two estimators had underestimated conduit hanger labor and left `$215,000` of unapproved delay claims in the WIP contract total. By cleaning up the WIP schedule, collecting `$95,000` in negotiated GC settlements, and recognizing the remaining fade 12 months prior to LOI, the seller passed the buyer’s QoE look-back test with `$0` in WIP adjustments.
  • Scenario C — $6.3M Austin Civil & Concrete Contractor (Cash-to-Accrual WIP Conversion): An Austin concrete and sitework contractor ran QuickBooks on a tax/cash basis with an off-book Excel WIP sheet updated only once a year for their bonding agent. Nine months before going to market, we integrated monthly `ASC 606` over/underbilling journal entries directly into the general ledger, cutting buyer diligence time by 45 days and defending a `5.4x` Adjusted EBITDA multiple.

Frequently Asked Questions: Contractor WIP Underbillings, Bonding & QoE in Texas

Why do surety underwriters and M&A QoE auditors view WIP Underbillings (Costs in Excess of Billings) as a red flag?

While an internal bookkeeper records Underbillings (Costs and Estimated Earnings in Excess of Billings, or CIEB) as a Current Asset under ASC 606 percentage-of-completion accounting, surety underwriters and M&A Quality of Earnings (QoE) auditors know that persistent underbillings usually mask unapproved change orders, underestimated field labor hours, or refusal to lower the Estimated Gross Margin on a troubled job (“Profit Fade”).

How do WIP Underbillings reduce a Texas contractor’s surety bonding capacity?

Surety underwriters calculate your aggregate bonding limit as a 10x to 15x multiple of “Adjusted Net Working Capital” (Current Assets minus Current Liabilities, after surety haircuts). If a surety disallows 50% to 100% of chronic or aged Underbillings (CIEB), a $500,000 Underbilling haircut reduces Adjusted Working Capital by $500,000—slashing your aggregate Texas bonding capacity by $5.0M to $7.5M overnight.

What is a QoE “Closed-Job Gross Margin Fade Look-Back Test” when selling a Texas construction business?

During M&A due diligence, the buyer’s Quality of Earnings (QoE) team compares the estimated gross margin reported on your open WIP schedule at 50%–75% completion against the final realized gross margin when those same jobs reached 100% completion. If your jobs historically fade from 28% estimated gross margin at 60% complete down to 18% at closeout, the buyer will haircut the Underbilling asset and reduce your trailing-12-month EBITDA on all currently open jobs.

What is a healthy Overbilling vs. Underbilling ratio for a Texas commercial contractor?

Best-in-class Texas commercial contractors maintain a Net Overbilled position (Billings in Excess of Costs and Estimated Earnings, or BIE) equal to 6% to 12% of active backlog by front-loading mobilization, engineering/submittals, and early rough-in on the AIA G702/G703 Schedule of Values—allowing the GC’s progress payments to fund project working capital while keeping Underbillings restricted to brief 15-day timing windows.